Dubl10,
If you want an increase in HP/tq from your "retune", you will have to utilize one of the higher octane settings (typically 89, 91 or 93) and then fill with the corresponding gas grade. Generally, the higher the octane requirements of the tune, the more additional HP it generates.
However, there are some advantages to using an 87 octane tune (at least w/ the Xcal2) with the S197 (2005) Mustang, especially if you have an automatic
trans. While you won't get any additional HP from the tune, you can/will get the following...
1) elimination of the WOT delay (which is really annoying)
2) elimination of rpm or top speed limiters.
3) recalibration of the tach/speedometer to compensate for wheel/tire/gearing changes
4) improved shift points & characteristics for auto transmissions.
Plus, you can always fill up w/ premium, load the 91 tune and go lead-footin it. Just be sure to reload the 87 when you go back to regular...