Called the website and no luck. I don't want to buy the entire grill again. Basically the light housing needs to be replaced. The lights themselves are OK, its the bulb casing that needs to be replaced as it's all white and messed up.
Here is the grill - I've searched online but no luck. Might be another 200 purchase if no other options. d'oh!
Mustang GT Style Grille w/ Fog Lights & Pony Cutout (05-09 V6)
Found these but I feel like the OEM's might be too small or too big.
http://www.americanmuscle.com/mustan...0509-pair.html