buy a bat (plastic wiffle ball style) and beat on him till he pays up. I suggest plastic since the wood will make him unresponsive too quickly.
If he won't pay I would go through insurance, his should pay (if he really has it) and be glad you filed a report. Good Luck
New England Fall Cruise Nov 5th
http://www.allfordmustangs.com/forums/2011-2014-mustang-talk/983122-new-england-fall-cruise-2016-a.html#post8555506PM RoboStang or me for details...let's go for a ride!