Yessir, I bought the inexpensive one first also (trying to save a minuscule amount of money, ie being cheap) and it failed right out of the box with the symptoms you've described. I then bought the nicer one, gray in color instead of black and it works fine. I think it said premium or something of that nature, it wasn't more than $5-7 more. Sent from AutoGuide.com Free App
2014 Sterling Gray Base 3.7 3 pedal FP6 Package - Borla Touring
1967 Coupe 200 C4 Auto 8" rear swap, front disc 5 lug conversion - 302 roller block (91 mark 7) GT40P heads, edelbrock performer intake, trick flow stg1 cam, edelbrock 600 cfm carb on my engine stand waiting for cooler weather.