From what I know the only time a supercharger is really a power robber is at idle. Since there is one more pulley to turn and it's not making enought boost to counteract the hp loss from turning the pulley. You can even see an increase in mileage (specially in trucks

) at highway speeds since you have only a pound or two (matters your gears....what rpm range you are in) of boost helping the motor to recieve air rather than sucking it in. But hey, i think AMG knows a little more about tuning cars then I do, and I have not read the article so i'm not sure.
Now that I just reread my response I see that i'm referring to Centrifugal s/c's. I'm not familar with roots or twin screw type s/c. They do make the most boost at low rpms so I can see how that type of s/c can cause economical loss when you don't "need" the power.
All in all it's a good idea...kinda gives you the same advantage as using Nitrous....pulley acts like an idler pully while not "engaged" and when you want the power it's there when you need it, when you don't want the power the engine acts as a n/a engine and gets better mileage.