Ford Mustang Forum - View Single Post - If not for a mustang, what would you buy?
View Single Post
post #46 of (permalink) Old 06-22-2010
5.0L Member
S197 Member
dontmatr's Avatar
Joined: May 2010
Location: Space Coast
Posts: 32

I've probably been playing around with the idea of getting a new car for about two years before finally ordering my GT back in April, and I considered quite a few different cars from different categories...

- Infiniti G35/37S 6MT sedan - I loved the way the car looked inside and out, and more than quick enough to be fun, and handled almost like a Nissan Z (not surprising, since the two cars share the same platform), yet had all the practicality of a 4-door sedan. The only thing that turned me off was the stock exhaust note and the horrendous method Infinti groups their option packages together (one option in one package I wanted would require me to select another package which had options I DIDN'T want), where checking two option boxes jacked the price up by almost $ thanks.

- Hyundai Genesis Coupe 3.8 - I was genuinely surprised by this car once I saw it in person. I'm not a fan the of the stock grille, but overall the exterior looked very sleek to me, and the interior didn't look too bad either (though still a bit on the cheap side). When driving the car it handled quite well, IMO better than my '06 GT, although it came up short in power/acceleration. Also liked the exhaust note, IMO better than VQ35/37 engines. In the end, the coupe just didn't have enough power to satisfy more, and paying $30+k for the Track version with Brembos and sportier suspension didn't sit too well with me (but, if they could somehow fit the 4.6L V-8 from the Genesis sedan or the upcoming 2.0L 274hp turbo four for the Sonata, I'd be considerably more interested)

- Nissan 370Z - I liked the small size of the car, and loved most of the layout of the cockpit. Also impressed by the handling and acceleration. But, like the infiniti, I didn't care for the sound of the VQ-series engine, and as a car I would use as a daily driver, completely impractical. Also, although I found the car quite comfortable once inside of it, getting in and out was literally a tremendous pain for me, due to my bad back.

- Dodge Challenger R/T - Never got to drive one, but love the styling of the car. Also liked the amount of interior room, but the dash layout seemed a bit too plain IMO. Nor did I care for the overall size and weight of the car. Also didn't like that I had to pay $1000 just to row my own gears.

- Honda Fit/Ford Fiesta - Yup, you read that right. Nope, I'm not kidding. There was a (thankfully brief) time where I considered getting out of the performance car game altogether and just wanted simple, economical, A-to-B transportation.

- Chevrolet Camaro SS - If there was no 5.0/6M available for 2011, this would've been the car I'd most likely buy. Not too crazy about the rear styling, or that the designers obviously placed form over function overall. Still, I do like the overall styling, and though I was really underwhelmed by the interior styling and lack of visibility and headroom (at least in moonroof-equipped cars), I liked the ride characteristics over bumpy roads thanks to the IRS, loved the power/torque/sound of the LS3 (still doesn't sound quite as good as the 5.0, though IMO) and for a car that weighed around 3900lb I thought it handled, accelerated and stopped quite well. In the end, the interior, lack of visibility and dealers unwilling to sell at/under invoice is what scratched the Camaro from my list.

2015 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack (Ivory White Pearl Tri-coat, Leather Interior Grp, Driver Convenience Grp, 8A)
2011 Ford Mustang GT Premium (Sterling Gray Metallic, HIDs, Security pkg., Brembo pkg., 3.55s, 6M)
dontmatr is offline  
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome