Being a Virgo stuff like that drives me crazy and I'd have to have it fixed. That being said however since it's a Premium can't you just tell Sync what to play thus avoiding the button altogether?
Hell, now I'm gonna be afraid to touch the buttons when my car gets here, LOL.
I haven't used Sync, and since it can't be used to set cruise control (where the paint flaked/peeled off on one of the buttons, and also there's a small matter of me not having, and hopefully never will have, a cell phone), I probably never will.
And being a Virgo as well, yes, while it's not that big of a deal in the grand scheme of things, it still bugs the hell out of me every time I get inside the car...
2015 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack (Ivory White Pearl Tri-coat, Leather Interior Grp, Driver Convenience Grp, 8A)
2011 Ford Mustang GT Premium (Sterling Gray Metallic, HIDs, Security pkg., Brembo pkg., 3.55s, 6M)