Mine doesn't match either. The yellow tint is pretty visible in this pic. When I was doing pre-purchase research on PW, I read that 05-09 PW Mustangs were prone to the same issue. I've had this picture for a while now, and I hadn't noticed it until specifically looking for it just now. If it's not bad enough for me to have noticed it in my 6 months of ownership so far, I'm not gonna sweat it. That mismatch is probably the last thing a person is going to notice on my car anyways, but I can understand how even if you're the only one who knows it, it can keep drawing your eyes toward it and eat at you.