If you goal is a much shorter throw then go for the barton or MGW. I am not so concerned with the shorter throw. I am however more concerned with it being smoother and more precise. You need to soul search on what you really want out of your shifter if the Steeda is not a short enough throw then cross it off your list. I do believe that with any of these shifters you really can't go to wrong.
2012 GT Premium, Ingot Silver, Brembo package, 3.73's, Clear Bra, GT500 Axle Backs, tint.