I'm having the same problem on the volume and track buttons. at night the light is shining through it. Neither of us have nails and the car only has 9k miles. Will be making an appt. with the dealer.
2011 6-Speed GT Convertible Premium, Ingot Silver, Brick Red/Cashmere Leather, Premier Trim W/Color Accent, Electronics Package, Security Package, HID Headlamps, Comfort Package, Brembo Brake Package and Rear Video Camera. FRPP air cleaner(K+N) and PROCAL re-tune.