All I see is curb rash and scratches. Offer him 200 if you are planning on plastidip, I wouldn't call those 'good' condition. 'Fair' is more accurate.
Yes, only one has curb rash and some of the chrome is peeling off but I know once I get done plastidipping them they will look really nice. We originally agreed $400 and then I told him about the damage and he lowered the price to $350. I think thats pretty fair because the all season Michelins on the rims are in good shape and would be a major upgrade from my worn out stock pirelis [bald and have 23k]. So this would definitely be a good buy as I need some tires anyways and why not have a nice 18" winter setup? So only question is will they fit properly? And is a converter a viable option?
Thanks for the help btw!