Ok I figure I will update this since I have "actually" fixed the problem.....yeah.
So in post #9 when I said "it's really nice not having belt slip issues"....I should have waited a few days before that post. It wound up creeping back, chirp, chirp, chirp. So I put the carbinite pulley on and it sounded awful. It sound 20 times worse. I wound up playing with the blower pulley some. I backed the pulley off the shaft maybe 1-2mm to see if the blower pulley was scraping on the back of the housing. I squirted some WD40 on the back side of the serpentine belt to see if that did anything. It did. The noise started backing off. So I squirted a tad more and a tad more and it would start subsiding and coming back pretty quick. I squirted some on the ribbed side of the belt and it went away and then started coming back. So I decided to replace the belt. I went down to NAPA and got the belt for my blower (Gates makes that belt btw). Put the belt on and the noise was still there. So, since I had a bunch of spare idler pullies laying around I started swapping a few of the idlers. No change in noise. So I figured I would take off the ilder on the tensioner. I pulled the tensioner off the car and I could move the pulley while it was still on the tensioner. Uh ohhh...and good. Found it. So to make sure that it was abnormal, I pulled that BBR pulley off and put another pulley on and it didn't move any. So I put the tensioner back on the car and the sound was gone. What a relief. Car is running strong and to top it off, the car pulls belt slip free all the way upto 6200rpms, which I haven't done since I first got the blower. Just so you guys know, I hand spun all the pullies on my car and NONE of them were showing any kind of play when spinning them. I imagine if I would have shook that pulley it would have shown, but I didn't do that. I just span it. So note to self, work the pullies in multiple directions. The stethoscope did indicate that noise was coming from that idler also. Anyway, now that I'm really done with that....a side note: It's not adviseable to use an impact wrench to put the blower pulley back on. You can chuck bearings and all kind of good stuff. Luckily, I didn't. Use a micro torch to put the pulley on. I'm sure the majority of folks out there have the common sense to not put a pulley on with an impact wrench.