All depends on taste.
Problem with eBay is that you never really know what you get till you get it. And the truth of the matter is, the more hands that those keys pass through, the less and less you know about your vehicle. I'm facing this trouble with mine and am finding myself completely unable to get in touch with the original owner.
As far as the rims go? Didn't the '86s come with the 4 lugs? If it is, and I think so, than you wouldn't be able to go back to the original wheels because those rims have 5 lugs.