I know you probably won't believe this but almost all the skins are made by the same company in Taiwan and sold to different distributors. In other words, the liklihood of the skins you bought from the two different retailers being made by the same manufacturer is very high.I bought one side from Mustangs Unlimited and the other from CJ Ponyparts. There is a big difference between the two. The one from CJ Ponyparts has very nice lines. I ended up selling the one on eBay and getting another from CJ's.