Hello.
That's odd.The one's in the first picture are correct for a convertible. The one's in the second picture are for a coupe/fastback.The inner rockers and the floor pans on a convertible are different from a coupe.I think that I would start from square #1 on this one.Check the 3rd and 4th digits of the vin.They should be 08, not 07. Sometimes people chop the roof off of a coupe and turn it into a convertible and 40 years is a long time.Who could really say what all might have happened to your car over all those years.If the vin is ok, it is possible that someone replaced the entire undercarriage of your car with that of a coupe.From firewall to gas tank and rocker molding to rocker molding they measure the same and that isn't nearly as difficult to do as is it might sound.Here are some pictures.The first is a coupe. The next one is my car, a 64 1/2 convertible with original floors and rockers.Excuse the less than perfect appearance.It's also original paint, carpet,seats and scuff plates. 