Can you post what it looks like on the passenger side? I'd like to see a comparison.
Other than except a possible gouge maybe about an inch in from the wheel edge I see no other obvious sign of damage, gouging, or leaks. Other than the area that I mentioned I see only an untouched black finish on the wheel.
It's a little odd to me that someone bought aftermarket wheels for the car but went with 17" and not 18", 19", or 20" in general. Stock 2013-14 GT wheels were actually 18" / 19” so those 17" wheels are even smaller in diameter than the originals. Had they stayed with the same diameter or upsized then clearance would likely not have been a problem. To go thru with the expense of buying aftermarket wheels it only makes sense to go up at least one size but that's just my opinion. Certainly, going smaller is usually not a good idea though.
In order to fit those particularly wide p305/45r17 tires the wheels would have to be 2.5-4.5" wider than the stock v6 17" wheels which were 7" wide. You would need 9.5-11.5" wheels for those tires.